Giving Under Attack: How Politicians Threaten Private Giving

Private giving is woven into the fabric of the American story. From a fledgling nation, to the great country we are now, the United States has benefited enormously from contributions made by its citizens to charitable institutions. This giving is a testament to the strength of our national character.

However, this rich philanthropic tradition is threatened by a misunderstanding of the difference between transparency and privacy. In short, transparency is applied to government programs and processes, but privacy is applied to its citizens as they seek to conduct their lives and pursue their passions.

Privacy as Protection

It’s not a new threat.

Throughout our history, politicians have sought to weaponized charity by demanding information from givers and using that information to silence or shame them for supporting groups or causes with which those same politicians disagreed.

In recent years, the push to divulge donation data has come from state attorneys, general, or state and local governments. The consequences of such policies are just as damaging to our freedom today as similar efforts at the national level during the past decades – specifically during the Civil Rights era. What could have been detrimental for supporters of desegregation now threatens modern freedom movements in diverse areas as drug policy, sexuality, and religious freedom.

So Why Does It Matter Now?

The loss of freedom for the few leads to a greater loss of freedom for the rest of us. Ultimately that undermines the bedrock principles on which America is founded.

If we lose donor privacy, I think we lose one of the most important aspects of civil society which is the ability of individuals freely to associate with one another, to use their dollars, to use their time, to address civil society problems. If we don’t do that then government does it for us and we lose the entire notion of a free democratic, free enterprise system.  –  Lawson Bader, President & CEO, DonorsTrust

Watch Under Attack, produced by the State Policy Network, to learn more about the threat donor disclosures can have on private giving and charity.


  • Lydia Pitea

    Lydia Pitea is the Marketing and Events Manager at DonorsTrust. Her primary responsibilities include coordinating events for the Trust, digital marketing, and assisting with content creation and donor communications. Lydia joined DonorsTrust in 2016 as a participant in the Koch Associate Program. Previously, she worked for PSEG, the major utility company of New Jersey, with the Project Public Affairs team and the Customer Technologies team. Lydia is a graduate of Montclair State University in New Jersey, where she received her B.S. in Business Administration with a concentration in Marketing and a minor in Political Science. Lydia is an avid reader and traveler, an excellent petter of cats, and a believer in all things magical (and yes, that means unicorns).

    View all posts

Start Protecting Your Intent Today.

Are you interested in giving to nonprofits that align with your conservative or libertarian values? If so, consider opening a simple, secure, tax-advantaged giving account with DonorsTrust.